« BitTorrent Search |
Main
| DC Circuit Rejects Challenge to Congress Removing Works from the Public Domain »
May 24, 2005
Google's Scan Plan Draws Critics
Posted by Alan Wexelblat
As I noted yesterday, Google's plan to produce a massive digital library is likely to arouse some ire. Today's AP story (here on Globeandmail.com) tells of objections from a group of academic publishers.
The association of nonprofit publishers is seeking information about how Google plans to protect copyrights, and is raising concerns because two publishers who have asked to have their material excluded from the project have not received any response from Google.
The issue is complicated, since Google's plans include scanning both works in and out of copyright, but only showing bibliographic information and excerpts from copyrighted works. Google also seems to say that copyright holders can have their works excluded from the project, but has not apparently responded to actual requests to do so.
My guess is that this will likely be settled amicably in a short time but it highlights how uncertain the entire area has become and perhaps gives a preview of the troubles that may occur when for-profit publishers become involved.
Comments (1)
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: IP Use
- RELATED ENTRIES
- Apple Jumps Into iBooks - With Hobnailed Boots
- On the Dissent in Golan v Holder
- Jonathan Coulton on Megaupload/Piracy
- Stallman on E-Book Evils & Privacy
- Admin Update
- Joe Konrath Claims USD 100,000 E-book Profits in Jan
- Nate Anderson vs the MPAA
- SF vs SF Ideas
1. Scote on May 24, 2005 1:59 PM writes...
It is interesting to see reaction as Google moves it's search technology into printed matter. The copyright issues are actually somewhat similar. To create a search engine for the internet or for printed matter Google has to *copy* copyrighted material to their servers and the same goes for printed matter.
Technically, to my non-lawyers knowledge, what Google does with the internet is illegal but is granted a free pass, in part because the material on the internet has to be copied via the internet to be viewed at all. Copying the content of books is only slightly different. Unlike the internet, there is no printed equivalent of a "norobots" or "nofollow" tag to automatically ask Google to skip printed matter.
Permalink to Comment