Here we'll explore the nexus of legal rulings, Capitol Hill
policy-making, technical standards development, and technological
innovation that creates -- and will recreate -- the networked world as we
know it. Among the topics we'll touch on: intellectual property
conflicts, technical architecture and innovation, the evolution of
copyright, private vs. public interests in Net policy-making, lobbying
and the law, and more.
Disclaimer: the opinions expressed in this weblog are those of the authors and not of their respective institutions.
In the column, called "The Down-Low on Exclusivity Clauses", Long talks about Amazon’s KDP Select program. This program, which Amazon introduced at the end of 2011, allows authors to sign up to have their books placed in the "Kindle Owner’s Lending Library". This (virtual) library allows Kindle owners to "borrow" one book per month. That is, they can download a free copy with no due date of any book on the list. Since the reader doesn't pay, Amazon has offered an enticement to e-book authors to have their books in the library. Amazon will put forward a pool of money and each time a book is borrowed the author of that book gets something from the pool.
According to Long's column, in January authors were getting USD 1.60 per borrow. That's not much, but it's not a huge amount less than most authors get on e-book sales, and in theory the author can get borrow money on top of royalty money. That's the upside. The downside is exclusivity. If you're being borrowed on a Kindle then you can't be read on other devices, including Kindle apps that run on other devices. In effect, you're agreeing to have your book locked to one device in order to help Amazon sell more devices that will (work with me here) further lock in readers. Awesome.
As usual in these sorts of situations where an author sits on the publicity/popularity curve says a lot about how good this deal is. If you're a New York Times bestselling author then your readers are likely all over the marketplace and single-device lock-in is bad for you. If you're an unknown and need to build readership numbers, then the extra publicity of being in the library may be a boost. But then again, what do you do if your unknown book turns into a hit and readers can't get it elsewhere? A new author may be crippling her audience reach by agreeing to this lock-in, without even knowing what the potential reach of that audience is.
Long tries to end her column on a balanced note; as she says, the situation wasn't exactly a rose garden in the days before e-books. Perhaps that's her professorial (she teaches at Boston College) fairness showing through. Me? I have only sympathy and faint contempt for people who feel they need to buy into someone else's exclusive locks. This may be why I don't own an e-book device myself.
I have owned a Kindle for over a year now, and I've been getting into reading a lot of books/stories from amateur artists. Most are under a dollar and are hit or miss. I agree that some of these authors are selling themselves short. The short memoir written by a US soldier, "The Princess of Kosovo", really touched my heart. The author has his story on there for 99 cents (he will earn only 33 cents for each sale)...and he has locked himself into Prime. Maybe he wasn't thinking and wanted to get as many reads as possible, but I'm pretty sure not to many people will be using their one free borrow a month for a 99 cent memoir; most people would just spend the 99 cents and use the borrow for a more expensive book. but, yes, I fully agree with your article. It's great that some authors can emerge from e-books, but a shame that most of these authors will be locked down the Kindle device.
1. Tammy on March 11, 2012 10:52 AM writes...
I have owned a Kindle for over a year now, and I've been getting into reading a lot of books/stories from amateur artists. Most are under a dollar and are hit or miss. I agree that some of these authors are selling themselves short. The short memoir written by a US soldier, "The Princess of Kosovo", really touched my heart. The author has his story on there for 99 cents (he will earn only 33 cents for each sale)...and he has locked himself into Prime. Maybe he wasn't thinking and wanted to get as many reads as possible, but I'm pretty sure not to many people will be using their one free borrow a month for a 99 cent memoir; most people would just spend the 99 cents and use the borrow for a more expensive book. but, yes, I fully agree with your article. It's great that some authors can emerge from e-books, but a shame that most of these authors will be locked down the Kindle device.
Permalink to Comment